Course Outline & Learning Outcomes: This course investigates the relationship of bioethics with truth-telling issues through the lens of culture and new understandings of the doctor-patient relationship. In the past twenty years, truth-telling has been studied in terms of duty, right, cultural nuance, morality, timing, emotional response, historical perspective and implicit bias. Four major themes frame the course content as specific learning outcomes and areas of understanding: Tensions surrounding Truth-telling, Truthfulness and Medical Ethics, Truth-telling and Cross-Cultural Medicine, and Contemporary challenges to truth-telling. On the practical level, students will apply the learning outcomes to case studies related to truth-telling issues thus testing the strength of the interdisciplinary nature of bioethics as it grapples with difficult issues such as those posed by the truth-telling debates. Finally, students will evaluate new paradigms of practical ways of delivering information truthfully that are rooted in the nature of truth as beneficial and liberating (John 8: 32).
BACK, A. − ARNOLD, R., «Discussing prognosis: ‘how much do you want to know?’ talking to patients who are prepared for explicit information»,
Journal of Clinical Oncology 24 (2006), 4209-4213.
BERLINGER, N., «What is meant by telling the truth: Bonhoeffer on the ethics of
disclosure», Studies in Christian Ethics 16 (2003), 80-92.
BLACKHALL, L. – FRANK, G. – MURPHY, S. – MICHEL, V., «Bioethics in a
Different Tongue: The Case of Truth-telling», Journal of Urban Health 7
(March 2001), 59-71.
CASSELL, Eric J., Talking with Patients: Volume 1 The Theory of Doctor-Patient
Communication, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA, 1987. (216 pages)
DeVRIES, Raymond & Subedi, Jonathan, (eds.), Bioethics & Society:
Constructing the Ethical Enterprise, Prentice Hall, Upper Saddle River, NJ,
1998. (276 pages) Especially the first four chapters
HAGERTY, R. – BUTOW, P. − ELLIS, P. et al., «Communicating with realism and
hope: incurable cancer patients’ views on disclosure », Journal of Clinical
Oncology 23 (2005), 1278-1288.
LETENDRE, Marie C., The Bioethical and Cultural Implications of the Truth-
Telling Debates, APRA-IF Press, Roma-Morola, 2010 (358 pages).
O’NEILL, Onora, Autonomy and Trust in Bioethics Cambridge University Press,
Cambridge, England, 2002. (192 pages)
PALMIERI, J. – STERN, T., «Lies in the Doctor-Patient Relationship», Primary
Care Companion Journal of Clinical Psychiatry 11 (2009), 163-168.
SURBONE, Antonella & Zwitter, Matjaž, Communication with the Cancer
Patient: Information ad Truth, Annals of the New York Academy of
Sciences, Volume 809, New York, 1997, (537 pages).
VEATCH, Robert M., Cross-Cultural Perspectives in Medical Ethics, Jones &
Bartlett Publishers, Sudbury, MA, 2000 (second edition). (369 pages)
ZALOT, Jozef & Guevin, Benedict, Catholic Ethics in Today’s World, St. Mary’s
Press, Winona, MN, 2008. (255 pages).